I had an interesting conversation with a friend the other day. They are pursuing religious studies and had to read a chapter on sin. The questions at the end of the chapter were rather personal, not at all what you would expect to encounter in an academic text. The whole notion of sin is deeply personal, to each of us. The questions from that book were clearly biased toward a view of sin that says that all sin is evil and should be hated.
That made me think of this whole notion of every sin being something evil. In the New Testament, sin is a greek word that means missing the mark. It is a hunting term. Doesn’t matter how far you miss the mark, it is a miss. It implies that you tried, doesn’t it? And I think that is what I find problematic with sin always being evil in nature. Was Eve engaging in evil? She was simply exercising her free will when she ate of the forbidden fruit. The disobedience was in going her own way, letting her ego (and Adam too!) lead the way to her actions. And that is sin, when we let our own ego lead us, instead of the ways of the Eternal for our lives.
See the difference? We would rather categorize everything in black and white terms, either/or if you will. But sin, going our ego’s way, is not either/or. It is, instead, both/and. We can do a list of good deeds that are sinful, if they are done to satisfy our ego, our own need. We can sin while we worship, if we enter worship for any reason other than to spend time with the Lover of our souls. Not what most of us have been taught at church is it? Sinners, in Jesus time, were those who could not pay the temple tax for their forgiveness. It was simply a state of being, a separateness. Good and evil were really not at issue, just the state they were in.
I don’t believe in “original sin”. For my Reformed brothers and sisters, I am sorry to say that I do not believe in “utter depravity”, a Calvinist term that says we are all bad, depraved from our very birth. Sorry, that does not jibe with the Creator looking at creation and saying, it is good! I believe we are all born with the capacity for great good. When we are old enough to actually choose our behavior, we are also old enough to choose to go our own way, to let our ego lead us. To let what we want lead us, instead of what is best for us.
The only thing that book got right was that sin is deeply personal. But instead of hating anything, especially ourselves, we need to embrace the sin of our own ego. Until we love ourselves, sin and all, we cannot lover or forgive others. In all the years I have been a therapist, it has become clear that the “demon” that binds most people is the demon of self-loathing. That demon that says you are not worth forgiving, cannot be forgiven, that you are unlovable. Now that is true sin, to believe that the Eternal can forgive anyone else, but you. In a strange way, that is the ultimate egotistical thinking, that you are the only one who is unforgiveable.
On the Cross, Jesus said, “tetalestai”, it is finished. Why can’t we believe that? Why is it so hard for us to receive the tender love and forgiveness of Abba, Daddy? It is finished you know? Once and forever and we are restored to the Garden of Eden, which has always represented the perfect relationship of love with the Eternal. When Jesus healed someone and said, “go and sin no more” did he really believe that the person would never sin again? Of course not! In the context of his time, Jesus was saying that the person should go and be free of the idea that they were still a sinner because they did not go to the Temple and pay for the sacrifice. He was saying, go on with your life and quit believing that you are damaged goods, a sinner. It is why I reject the utter depravity notion. That teaches the opposite of what Christ said. We are not damaged goods, we are wonderful creations full of potential to heal the world.
Today, let’s all go and “sin no more”. Today, let us believe that it truly is finished and that we no longer have to believe that we are sinners. Let us do as St. Francis suggested, “Preach the Gospel at all times, use words if necessary”. Let’s forgive ourselves first, forgive the world second, and Love with all our might.
TMM